Manual SIP Tracking vs Automated SIP Performance Trackers

Manual SIP tracking is the process of manually tracking your systematic investment plan in different mutual fund schemes. Manually tracking your SIPs typically involves:

• Recording SIP investments on a spreadsheet

• Checking NAV periodically

• Calculating the total invested amount and the current portfolio value manually

• Reviewing CAS (Consolidated Annual Statements) 

• Checking mutual fund factsheets that outline information on the performance of MF schemes, historical returns, portfolio composition, etc.

The manual SIP tracking method shouldn’t be confused with automated SIPs. Under SIP automation, you set a date when your money is to be debited from the account at regular intervals. But even after this investment automation, your SIP performance tracking can still be manual.

Here’s how you can track your SIP performance manually:
 

1. Review the Monthly Fund Fact Sheet

Every fund house publishes a monthly fact sheet on its website. This sheet shows performance, portfolio allocation, and risk measures, such as standard deviation and the Sharpe ratio. You can review this sheet to understand how your investment in particular mutual fund scheme is performing and where your money is deployed.
 

2. Track NAV and Compare with the Benchmark

You can visit the mutual fund’s website to check the fund’s Net Asset Value regularly. When doing so, you can compare the fund’s performance with its benchmark index to see whether it aligns with the broader market. This gives you context instead of judging returns in isolation. 
 

3. Compare with Peer Funds in the Same Category

To assess SIP performance over the last 10 years or shorter periods, compare your scheme with similar funds in the same category. This helps you see whether your fund is consistent or lagging behind other options with a similar investment mandate.
 

4. Check Your Consolidated Account Statement (CAS)

Your CAS provides a consolidated view of all your mutual fund investments across schemes of different fund houses. Reviewing it periodically helps you track the total invested amount, current value, and overall SIP performance without relying on a SIP performance tracker or external dashboard.

Manual SIP performance tracking may seem difficult at first, but it has a few benefits:

• Full control over data: You enter each SIP instalment yourself, keeping yourself aware of your SIP investment journey and how your corpus is growing over long term.
   

• Better understanding of performance: When you calculate SIP performance manually, you understand compounding and how market movements affect your investment.
   

• No reliance on apps or platforms: You are not dependent on a SIP performance tracker to see your data.

Here’s a list of the disadvantages of tracking your SIPs manually:

• Takes time: Keeping a spreadsheet updated every month sounds simple, but it can become a chore, especially if you have several SIPs and a busy schedule. It’s easy to postpone updates and lose track.
   

• Easy to make mistakes: A wrong date, missed instalment, or small formula error can change your SIP performance numbers without you realising it.
   

• Needs comfort with numbers: Calculating XIRR or other ratios can feel confusing if you’re not used to working with formulas.

An automated SIP performance tracker is an online tool that helps you monitor all your SIP investments in one place. Instead of manually updating spreadsheets, the tracker pulls data automatically and shows you how your SIP mutual fund investments are performing.

It typically allows you to:

• Fetch live NAV updates automatically

• Calculate XIRR without manual formulas

• Show the total invested amount versus the current value

• Compare funds using a built-in SIP screener

• Display risk-adjusted performance metrics

• Review historical SIP performance, including SIP performance over the last 10 years in a particular fund

Many online portfolio trackers also provide dashboards that show asset allocation, performance trends, and alerts. This reduces the effort required for SIP tracking and helps you monitor performance more efficiently, without the need for constant manual work.

While the steps to use an automated SIP tracker can vary depending on your platform, here’s how most work:

• Log in to your tracking platform.

• Choose the option to sync or import your mutual fund investments.

• Complete the quick verification step (usually through an OTP).

• Once verified, your SIPs and mutual fund holdings will appear together in one place.

After syncing, you can filter performance metrics such as XIRR, total invested amount, current value, and historical SIP performance. Most platforms also provide visual insights and comparisons, helping you understand trends, consistency, and overall portfolio behaviour more clearly.

Here’s why automated SIP tracking may be better:

• Real-time updates: Your SIP performance refreshes automatically as NAV changes. You don’t have to visit different fund websites to see the latest value. Everything updates in one place.

• Automatic XIRR calculation: The tracker calculates your actual annualised return automatically. You don’t need to open spreadsheets or apply complicated formulas to know how your SIP investment is doing.

• Clear view of risk: Many trackers show how much your fund has fallen during market corrections and how your investment journey has been. 

• Easy-to-read dashboards: Clean charts and graphs make it easier to understand how your SIP has grown over time, instead of trying to interpret raw numbers.

While convenient, automated tracking has its drawbacks.

• Dependence on platforms: When you use an automated tracker, you are trusting the app or website to show accurate SIP tracking data. If there is a delay or error, you may not immediately notice it.

• Too much information: Many dashboards show several charts and metrics. If you’re not sure what really matters, all that data can feel confusing instead of helpful.

• Temptation to check often: Since updates are real-time, you might end up checking your SIP performance too frequently and reacting emotionally to normal market movements.

So, both methods can track SIP performance, but the benefit of the automated method is that it provides deeper insights with way less effort.

When trying to choose between manual SIP tracking and an automated SIP tracker, the decision depends on a number of factors like: 

• Your preferences

• The time and effort you’re willing to put in

• Which parameters you wish to track

• Your comfort with crunching numbers

When Manual SIP Tracking Makes Sense

Manual tracking may suit investors who:

• Prefer limited monitoring

• Have only one or two SIPs

• Enjoy spreadsheet analysis

• Want high engagement with their data

When Automated SIP Tracking Is More Suitable

Automated tracking may suit investors who:

• Have multiple SIPs across funds

• Want XIRR and rolling returns visibility

• Need risk-adjusted performance metrics

• Prefer structured dashboards

Avoiding Common SIP Tracking Mistakes

Regardless of which SIP tracking method you choose, try to avoid these mistakes:

• Checking performance too frequently

• Switching funds based on short-term underperformance

• Comparing SIP returns with lump-sum returns

• Ignoring volatility and drawdowns

Tracking your SIP isn’t about checking it every time the market moves. It’s about knowing how it’s doing over the long run and whether it still fits your goals.

You can track it on your own or use an app to do it for you. Both are fine. Just make sure you review it from time to time and don’t let short-term market swings push you into quick decisions.

• An Investor Education and Awareness Initiative by Tata Mutual Fund. 

• To know more about KYC documentation requirements and procedure for change of address, phone number, bank details, etc., please visit: https://www.tatamutualfund.com/deshkarenivesh

• Please deal only with registered Mutual Funds, details of which can be verified on the SEBI website under ‘Intermediaries / Market infrastructure institutions.’

• All complaints regarding Tata Mutual Fund may be directed to service@tataamc.com and/or https://scores.sebi.gov.in/ (SEBI SCORES portal) and/or https://smartodr.in/login

• Nomination is advisable for all folios opened by an individual, especially with sole holding, as it facilitates an easy transmission process. 

• This communication is a part of the investor education and awareness initiative of Tata Mutual Fund.