Year 2009 could be termed a watershed year for the
Indian Mutual Fund (MF) industry. The winds of
change have arrived. In fact the India Mutual Fund
industry has been ahead of the world in adopting
change and the forces of change have begun to chart a
new course for the industry. But as we all know,
“change”, even for the better, usually is difficult to
accept but in the end it brings growth and prosperity.
What is clearly emerging from the moves being made
by policy makers is that the industry is embarking on
a volume based growth path. This means that there
would be pressures on margins but they would be
compensated by larger volumes. And larger volumes
would call for appropriate marketing strategies.
Background
MF penetration is low at around 14% of GDP (GDP = Approx. Rs. 53 lakh crore - Source: Statistical
Outline of India 2008-09; Total Industry AUM = Rs.
7.4 lakh crore - Source: AMFI). As per the Invest India
Incomes and Savings Survey 2007 of individual wage
earners in the age group of 18 to 59 years, conducted
by IIMS Dataworks, only 1.6 percent are invested in
mutual funds (Source: KPMG-CII Report ).
Notwithstanding this the Indian financial market
offers great potential. After all, there are 500 million
bank account holders and the Gross Domestic
Savings are pegged at 36%. However only serious
players will succeed due to the large investments and
huge commitments needed to dip into this pool of
opportunities.
In this context, we have been fortunate to have seen
such strategies play out successfully in the not too distant past. The “sachet” phenomenon of the FMCG
industry has been etched in several bestselling
management books as case studies. And very recently
the stupendous growth witnessed in the mobile phone
industry was again around a volume driven “inviting
price” strategy. Having seen their successes one can
only draw encouragement from them. Consumer pull
is set to become the key driving force for the industry.
An appropriate strategy would be needed to unlock
this potential.
While change has been adopted, the next
challenge is to see how we adapt in this
context where every constituent of the
MF landscape would have a role to
play. The various areas of the
industry will evolve as we
move into the future and
some of these have
been discussed in
the next few
pages.
Industry
The industry could undergo
a wave of consolidation. The
industry players of the future will
be the ones prepared to invest
purposefully in their brands, on services
and in technology. The focus on volumes will
increase. It will no longer be about selling more to
the same people but more about selling the right
products to a larger mass of retail investors. Focus on
cost reduction will be high because sales, marketing
and investor education costs would go up.
Evolving technology at a breakneck speed will be the
biggest enabler in driving up productivity. Service
levels will get a fillip up from new advanced
technologies. Every available technology will be
leveraged to bring down avoidable cost in order to
increase the productivity of operations. Unless this is done the drive to garner volumes will not gain
momentum. There are 400 million mobile
connections in India. The mobile platform will get
busier by the day and web based technologies will
gather pace to make both communication and
transactions efficient.
Manufacturers and distributors will both enhance
their absolute earnings on the back of large volumes
and a large portion of these earnings will get ploughed
back into the brands, technology, investor
education etc.
The emergence of a single identification
number will make the process of
participation simpler and faster.
This would go a long way in
accelerating market
penetration and
market activity.
There is very
little doubt that
the retail segment
will come to dominate
the industry going forward
into the future. The number of
investors would be the “metric” of
the industry along with AUM.
Brands with a large number of retail
investors will emerge as industry leaders.
Advisory fee could become a reality in keeping with
the evolving nature of investment instruments. While
astronomical returns will become a rarity with most
returns hovering around the benchmark index, the
investor will seek to maximize his opportunities
across investment instruments. The system will make
it easy for him to ensure that his money works a lot
harder and in keeping with this savings account will
lose some significance going forward. This will give a
new lease of life to fixed income products like liquid
funds.
Distribution
The marriage with technology will give distribution
an altogether new dimension. While city folks may
not realize this, our fellow countrymen in the
hinterlands are not integrated to the MF industry. But
technology is on the verge of giving rise to one
common “web based” transactional platform which
will ensure that the efficiency of participation and
interaction with MF products will become the same
across the length and breadth of the country.
Distributor Houses have a great opportunity to ride
this wave of change by scaling up their operations and
building their own brands. Their positioning will
undergo a sea change as they start to occupy the
advisory and wealth management positions. The
advisor’s stature will enhance from that of an
‘enabler’ to that of a ‘solution provider’ i.e. they will
begin to assume a role perhaps as important as the
family doctor. However, as a corollary, they will need
to invest further capital into their business.
The distributors' advice will get customized and will
be in accordance with the investor's life stage and
would start resembling the approach of the life
insurance agent. Dynamic allocation of assets with
changing market conditions and life stages will
become the kind of advice and service that will chart
the future course. This would be the kind of service
that would cement the client advisor relationship and
ensure a steady stream of income for the latter.
Just as the financial meltdown in Wall Street has
driven sense in the minds of many that chasing Y-o-Y
growth is not sustainable, in the same manner
advisors will have to embark upon a different path to
fulfill the client's lifespan investment needs. He will
transform from being a transaction provider to a
solutions provider. Thus, all kinds of products
ranging from fixed income, insurance and equity
products will be wrapped and made into a single offer.
Manufacturers will work closely with distributor
partners and set joint goals and they too are likely to
set up huge distribution companies. IFAs will band
together under a common brand umbrella that could
take the shape of a franchisee model. Quality of
outlets would improve going forward. Not only will it
bring a dash of professionalism but would also enable
the advisor to charge a premium.
Products
Products will get simple. The idea will be to show
more than to hide. The biggest communication
challenge will be to simplify and clarify. Product
pruning and consolidation could be seen in the future.
All in all, product complexity will reduce and sensible
financial planning will come to the fore. SIP will gain
prominence: Small priced products like SIP will
become the drivers of this movement. They would be
the future drivers of business. They could
revolutionize the market just as the “sachets” did for
the FMCG industry and “pre-paid” did for the
telecom industry. These small value products are
endowed with the potency to rip open the market
potential.
Indians have always been in favour of fixed income
products. The large pool of Bank FDs is a reflection of
this. Hence these products would gain importance
and one could see them casting a larger shadow in the
investor's portfolio. Hence efficiently managed fixed
income products will have a larger role to play in the
days ahead.
Retail product would get a lot simpler. A minor wave
of product consolidation could help in this cause. The
significance attached to “risk” as a key parameter of
investment would substantially go up. The gap
between product performances with the benchmark
for most diversified funds could start diminishing as
the size and pace of the industry starts gaining
momentum. Pressure on management fees could also
increase as “returns” start inching towards the
benchmark. Market segments would get distinct and
it would get easier to customize products. Structured
products would evolve and consolidate. Proliferation
of new products would get curtailed. Very few new
products can be expected to dawn upon the landscape
unless of course blessed with a significantly unique
value proposition.
Investors
Investors will be made to feel more integrated and
would make informed investment decisions.
Investor expectation would change from chasing
highest returns to sensible investment planning.
Financial planning will find its rightful place in the
sun and would evolve in the way it was envisaged. The
investor, as in the case of other products, will gravitate
towards the brand that aligns to their own self belief.
The brands that grow and flourish in the financial
landscape would be those that engender “a feeling of
trust” around the brand persona.
Understanding and comprehension of products
would improve. This would be aided by design of
simpler products at the retail level. Investors would
get a lot more conscious of the risk attached to their
investment products. The global meltdown in the
financial markets has given “risk” an altogether new
dimension. While returns will continue leading the
pack of financial products, the dangers of being at full
throttle have been ingrained in the minds of investors
and will continue to guide their investment decisions. Hence risk will
come to play a
dominant role in
investment
decisions.
Lower income
investors will be
taken into the fold: The investment culture will seep
deep into the social landscape. Just as “pre-paid”
unlocked the potential of the telecommunications
sector by lowering down the ticket size, one can
expect to see similar dynamics play out in the
investment landscape sooner rather than later. SIP
ticket size could reduce to as low as Rs 50 per month
or even Rs 10 a day. New technologies would drive
down the cost to such an extent that extending these
facilities would cease to be a challenge.
Pricing
A differential pricing environment could emerge in
keeping with the investor segment and fund
management expertise and attention. As such,
various packages are being designed in keeping with
the service levels that could be offered. In the early
days, one could expect to see investor resistance to
pay for service or negotiate hard. But as the value
proposition being offered would get clearer, such
resistance would give way to a larger acceptance to
pay for the perceived value and service being rendered
to them. The margins of MF manufacturers are likely
to get squeezed in keeping with the expenditure that
needs to be made towards brand building and
education. The role of technology gains significance
in this context to rein in the cost and build up
productivity.
Training and Learning
One could expect to see organizations backing their
marketing plans with substantial investments for
training and learning. Thus playing “lip service” alone will not suffice in the future. Education will
become the bedrock to bring about the growth in the
industry. Quality of personnel will get enhanced.
Training and learning will gain prominence giving rise
to professional finishing courses. Knowledge
dissemination in friendlier formats would gain
importance. One could see mobile and web based
learning models play a key role in perpetuating
knowledge. Financial literacy levels will rise and over
time become an integral portion of the curriculum in
colleges.
Engagement with investors will become intense.
Investors will want to know more and effective
comprehension and communication will become the
biggest challenge for advisors. The changes will
evolve the advisory role even further.
Communication and Media
Brand building in the MF industry was nearly
non-existent. Communication was mainly centered
on “information”. One can see this certainly
changing going forward. More emphasis on the brand
building will come to the fore. Brand building while
being necessary will not suffice by itself. It will
be come impe rat ive to run “Knowl edge
Management” programs for the investor so that
the investor feels empowered to take educated
decisions.
Communication will increasingly be around the
image and value of the corporate brands. Brands will
forge stronger relationships with investors. The trust
in the brands will be a function of the brand's ability
to partner and guide the investor through his lifespan.
Abrupt and impulsive style will lose traction. Mobile and internet will become dominant platforms.
Those who are unable to comprehend this
opportunity will find their brands getting obsolete
and irrelevant.
All in all, 2009-10 is thus all set to become the
harbinger of change for the Mutual Fund industry
and would re-shape the various constituents that
come together to form the industry.
|